“It is not strength that overcomes darkness, but light”

– Celebrimbor, The Rings of Power

“It is not strength that overcomes darkness, but light” – A Reflection on Celebrimbor’s Philosophy in The Rings of Power

In J.R.R. Tolkien’s Middle-earth, characters constantly grapple with the ever-looming threat of darkness—both literal and metaphorical. The Rings of Power adaptation gives life to this eternal struggle through many characters, none more compelling than the Elven smith Celebrimbor. His wisdom, encapsulated in the line “It is not strength that overcomes darkness, but light,” offers a powerful meditation on the nature of good, evil, and the means by which they are defeated.

This idea resonates deeply within the mythos of Middle-earth, where darkness and light are not merely physical states but symbolic forces that represent good and evil. For Celebrimbor, the grandson of Fëanor, the creator of the Silmarils, these concepts carry profound significance. As one who helped craft the Rings of Power, Celebrimbor stands at the intersection of creation and destruction, light and darkness, and his statement suggests a belief in the transformative power of illumination, wisdom, and hope rather than brute force.

The Significance of Light in Tolkien’s World…

The content below was originally paywalled.

Throughout Tolkien’s works, light is a recurring motif associated with divinity, hope, and redemption. From the Two Trees of Valinor to the Silmarils, light symbolizes the purest form of creation, often imperiled but never entirely extinguished. Conversely, darkness represents corruption, the will to dominate, and the destruction of beauty and harmony.

For Celebrimbor, the notion that “light” overcomes darkness speaks to a higher moral truth in Tolkien’s world. The real victory over darkness is not merely physical or through martial prowess, but through inner light—qualities like love, selflessness, and the preservation of beauty and wisdom. This philosophy is crucial, especially in the context of The Rings of Power, where Celebrimbor finds himself both a creator of great beauty and a target of Sauron’s deceit. His rings, meant to preserve and enhance, are eventually subverted by the One Ring, a tool of overwhelming dominance.

Strength vs. Light

At first glance, Celebrimbor’s distinction between “strength” and “light” might seem counterintuitive in a world filled with mighty warriors, epic battles, and powerful artifacts. Strength—physical, magical, and political—plays a prominent role in shaping Middle-earth’s fate. However, Celebrimbor’s philosophy indicates a deeper understanding of how true victory is won.

Strength, in its rawest form, often seeks to dominate and control. Morgoth and Sauron, the two great antagonists of the First and Second Ages, embody this desire for power. They aim to conquer and subjugate through force, fear, and manipulation. Yet, time and again, Tolkien shows that such power cannot last. Strength rooted in domination is inherently self-destructive, breeding mistrust, corruption, and eventual downfall.

Light, by contrast, represents a force that seeks to illuminate, nurture, and preserve. It is tied to wisdom, the ability to see beyond one’s immediate desires, and the humility to serve a greater purpose. Galadriel’s phial, a small vessel containing the light of Eärendil’s star, plays a pivotal role in Frodo and Sam’s journey, symbolizing the way even a small flicker of hope can push back the encroaching darkness. This is the kind of power Celebrimbor champions—not one that overwhelms through might, but one that endures through resilience, compassion, and vision.

Celebrimbor’s Tragic Insight

Celebrimbor’s statement is particularly poignant when viewed through the lens of his own tragic arc. As a master craftsman, he creates the Three Rings for the Elves—Vilya, Nenya, and Narya—with the intent to heal and preserve Middle-earth in the face of time and decay. Unlike the One Ring, these are not instruments of control but of protection and enhancement, meant to bolster the natural world rather than subjugate it.

However, Celebrimbor’s light—his desire to preserve and heal—is ultimately manipulated by Sauron, who uses deception rather than force to corrupt the Rings of Power. This highlights a tragic irony: Celebrimbor, who understood the futility of raw strength, fell prey to darkness not through violence but through cunning. Yet, even in defeat, his creations endure. The Three Elven Rings remain untainted by Sauron’s influence, proving that the light within them—embodied in Elrond, Galadriel, and Gandalf—can withstand the shadow.

The Message for Middle-earth and Beyond

Celebrimbor’s assertion that “light” overcomes darkness is not only a moral statement but a guiding principle for the characters who fight to preserve Middle-earth. It reflects a truth that underpins Tolkien’s broader mythology: that goodness is found not in dominance, but in the willingness to shine a light for others, to preserve beauty and life in the face of decay. Characters like Frodo, Sam, and Aragorn triumph not because of their strength in battle, but because of their endurance, compassion, and the belief that even the smallest light can push back the greatest evil.

For viewers and readers of The Rings of Power, Celebrimbor’s words offer a timeless lesson. In a world often obsessed with power and control, it is the qualities of light—hope, wisdom, and love—that create lasting change. Middle-earth’s history is filled with wars and conquests, but its enduring beauty and hope come from those who choose to build, nurture, and illuminate rather than those who seek to dominate through strength alone.

Celebrimbor’s wisdom that “it is not strength that overcomes darkness, but light” resonates far beyond the confines of Tolkien’s legendarium. It speaks to the heart of what makes Tolkien’s work so enduring—its belief in the power of hope and moral courage over sheer might. In a world where darkness often seems overwhelming, it is the light we carry within us that has the greatest power to overcome it. Just as Celebrimbor’s rings were crafted with care and intention, so too must we build and preserve the light within ourselves, even when the shadows grow long.